When it comes to asphalt roofing shingles, the market is crowded with big-name brands: CertainTeed, Owens Corning, GAF, and others. At American Roofing and Renovation, we’ve reviewed performance, warranties, and durability—and our top recommendation consistently goes to CertainTeed, especially for homeowners seeking reliable, long-term protection paired with aesthetic versatility. 1. Material Construction & Durability CertainTeed shingles are built with a thicker, dual-layer design that improves resistance to high winds and impact. One comparison notes that “CertainTeed has a slight edge…tend to be thicker and heavier, making them more resilient against extreme weather conditions” Roof Crafters+14Contractor Starter Theme+14Bill Ragan Roofing+14. Owens Corning, however, integrates their patented SureNail technology for enhanced wind resistance. In side-by-side tests, Owens Corning scored 5/5 on granule loss while CertainTeed scored slightly lower, though still strong builtrightroofs.com+3roofinginsights.com+3Contractor Starter Theme+3. GAF shingles also rate high in wind warranties, but industry Rokers cite CertainTeed for its heavier feel and robust granule retention The Spruce+15TexAgs+15Bill Ragan Roofing+15. 2. Impact & Storm Resilience CertainTeed’s premium Landmark series carries a Class 4 impact rating, offering top-tier hail protection—a rating not always matched by competitors Prairie Exteriors and Painting. Owens Corning’s Duration series also provides strong storm resilience but rates Class 3 in impact tests roofinginsights.com+9Prairie Exteriors and Painting+9Bill Ragan Roofing+9. 3. Energy Efficiency & Algae Resistance CertainTeed’s arena includes shingles with Cool-roof technology and StreakFighter algae resistance, which protect against solar heat buildup and unsightly black streaks The Spruce+15CertainTeed+15Roof Crafters+15. Owens Corning counters with its Cool Roof Collection and long-lasting algae warranties (up to 25 years), slightly longer than CertainTeed in many cases Roof Crafters+2Prairie Exteriors and Painting+2builtrightroofs.com+2. 4. Warranty and Value CertainTeed offers a lifetime limited warranty plus the option to upgrade to SureStart PLUS, covering materials, labor, tear-off, and disposal for up to 50 years Prairie Exteriors and Painting. Owens Corning matches with a competitive lifetime warranty but can limit coverage for tear-off and disposal unless upgraded Reddit+2Bill Ragan Roofing+2Prairie Exteriors and Painting+2. GAF is known for its extensive warranty options, but roofers still favor CertainTeed’s weight and granule retention for longevity Reddit+15TexAgs+15roofinginsights.com+15. 5. Professional & Industry Endorsements Roofing professionals frequently recommend CertainTeed Landmark shingles for their performance; one roofer posted: “I personally recommend Landmark Certainteed shingles … installed correctly in just about any weather can withstand very high winds and slopes.” Bill Ragan Roofing+2Roof Crafters+2Reddit+2Reddit Industry testing sites such as RoofingInsights review the Landmark shingles positively: “Certainteed’s Landmark shingles are a great option for any home, and they can provide superior protection at a great price.” roofinginsights.com+1roofinginsights.com+1 Customer-oriented renovator sites note that CertainTeed “excel in terms of variety, durability, and energy efficiency” even though pricing may be higher Best Exteriors Inc. 🏆 Summary Comparison Table Feature CertainTeed Owens Corning GAF Wind Resistance Up to 130 mph Up to 130 mph (SureNail) Up to 130 mph Impact Rating Class 4 Class 3 Varies Algae Warranty Up to 25 yrs 25 yrs (prorated) Varies Energy Efficiency Cool-roof shingles Cool Roof Collection Some cool options Thickness/Weight Heavy, durable Lighter, engineered Varies Warranty Coverage Lifetime + SureStart PLUS Lifetime, tear-off optional Extensive Online Sources Recommending CertainTeed: RoofingInsights: “Landmark shingles are a great option…superior protection at a great price” CertainTeed+4Bill Ragan Roofing+4builtrightroofs.com+4Bill Ragan Roofing+4Prairie Exteriors and Painting+4Roof Crafters+4Roof CraftersRoof Craftersbuiltrightroofs.com+1Prairie Exteriors and Painting+1 BuildWithKraft.com: Notes CertainTeed shingles are thicker and more resilient in extreme weather Contractor Starter Theme PrairieExteriors.com: Highlights CertainTeed’s Class 4 impact rating Prairie Exteriors and Painting BillRaganRoofing.com: Lists CertainTeed among top asphalt shingles for quality and warranty Reddit+15Bill Ragan Roofing+15Bill Ragan Roofing+15 Reddit/r/Roofing: Users personally recommend Landmark shingles for harsh conditions roofinginsights.com+4Reddit+4Reddit+4 Considerations for Homeowners Cost vs. Value: CertainTeed typically costs a bit more, but the premium often pays off through better durability, thicker shingles, and stronger warranties. Installer Certification: To access full warranties (like SureStart PLUS), use a CertainTeed Select Contractor—that’s where American Roofing and Renovation comes in. Local Weather: In Georgia’s storm-prone climate, the extra storm resistance and Class 4 impact rating of CertainTeed can offer better protection and peace of mind. 🔧 Working with American Roofing and Renovation As a certified installer of CertainTeed products, American Roofing and Renovation ensures proper installation to qualify for full warranty protection. We guide you through shingle options, energy efficiency features, and ideal color choices for enhanced curb appeal. 📞 Ready to Explore CertainTeed? Contact us to learn more or schedule a free inspection: 📞 478 328 ROOF (7663)🌐 americanroofingandrenovation.com/contact-us/ Explore more of our blog content here: americanroofingandrenovation.blogspot.com/ Whether you choose CertainTeed, Owens Corning, GAF, or another brand, informed decisions and expert installation mean a stronger, more valuable roof. We’re here to help you every step of the way.